Paperdoi:10.1177/20552076261497280

Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring

Venue listedDated Oct 20, 2026Added Nov 19, 2026

  • BE
  • FH
  • OS
  • EH

Authors: Boysen ES, Færevik H, Ose SO, Eitzen I (SINTEF Health Research; Sunnaas Rehabilitation Hospital)

Digital Health 12 (2026), SAGE; online 2026-10-20 (PubMed-indexed 2026-11-18)

TL;DR

Thirty-four working adults used a wrist wearable and a bedside radar for up to six weeks (620 matched nights, >500,000 epochs), with no PSG. Total sleep time agreed well (ICC 0.91, wearable 3.8 min lower, limits of agreement about ±70 min), but wake after sleep onset did not (ICC 0.34), and 4-stage agreement was only moderate (kappa ≈ 0.49), with the wearable scoring more light sleep.

Abstract

Objective

Polysomnography (PSG) is the gold standard for sleep assessment but is intrusive and unsuitable for long-term, real-world monitoring. This study compared a wrist-worn wearable device and a radar-based nearable as potential alternatives for naturalistic, home-based sleep monitoring in a working adult population.

Method

Thirty-four working adults (mean age 45.3 years) used both devices for up to six weeks, yielding 620 matched sessions and over 500,000 30-second sleep epochs. Agreement between devices was assessed for total sleep time (TST), wake after sleep onset (WASO), and device-derived sleep stage classification using intraclass correlation (ICC), Bland-Altman analysis and kappa statistics.

Results

Agreement was excellent for TST (ICC = 0.91), with wearable underestimating sleep duration by a mean of 3.8 minutes (95% limits of agreement: −74 to +67 minutes, a band of approximately 140 minutes). Agreement was low for WASO (ICC = 0.34), with systematic magnitude-dependent discrepancies. Epoch-level analyses showed substantial agreement for 2-state sleep–wake classification (PABAK = 0.78) but only moderate agreement for 4-state classification (Cohen’s κ ≈ 0.49), with the wearable classifying more epochs as light sleep, particularly when the nearable identified wake or REM.

Discussion

While the two device classes provide compatible population-level estimates of total sleep duration, agreement for wake detection and algorithmic sleep stage classification was considerably lower. These findings underscore the need for caution against interchangeable use of wearable and nearable devices for individual-level monitoring or research outcomes dependent on wake or sleep stage metrics.

Verbatim from the publisher's DOI record (opens in a new tab) · Publisher licence: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Results on ChatPPG leaderboards

All leaderboards

No results from this paper on ChatPPG leaderboards yet. Browse the leaderboards.

Tasks & signals

Tasks

Sleep staging

Keywords

SleepWearable Vs NearableHome SleepAgreementBland AltmanTstWasoSleep Staging

How it works

How Method works: Setup → Method → TargetSetup: Signals (ppg, accel, radar). Method: Method. Target: Sleep staging.SetupSignals: ppg, accel, radarSignalsppg, accel, radarMethodMethodTargetSleep stagingSleep staging

Cite this paper

Cite this paper with the fields recorded here. Check it against the publisher before submitting.

Boysen, E. S., Færevik, H., Ose, S. O., & Eitzen, I. (2026). Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring. Digital Health 12 , SAGE. https://doi.org/10.1177/20552076261497280
Boysen, E S, H Færevik, S O Ose, and I Eitzen. 2026. "Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring." Digital Health 12 , SAGE. https://doi.org/10.1177/20552076261497280.
Boysen, E. S., Færevik, H., Ose, S. O. and Eitzen, I. (2026) 'Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring', Digital Health 12 , SAGE. doi: 10.1177/20552076261497280.
Boysen, E S, et al. "Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring." Digital Health 12 , SAGE, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1177/20552076261497280.
E. S. Boysen, H. Færevik, S. O. Ose, and I. Eitzen, "Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring," Digital Health 12 , SAGE, 2026, doi: 10.1177/20552076261497280.
@article{boysen2026comparing,
  title         = {{Comparing wearable and nearable devices for sleep monitoring: A within-subject comparison of wrist-worn wearable and radar-based nearable devices for naturalistic home-based sleep monitoring}},
  author        = {Boysen, E. S. and Færevik, H. and Ose, S. O. and Eitzen, I.},
  year          = {2026},
  journal       = {Digital Health 12 , SAGE},
  doi           = {10.1177/20552076261497280}
}

Added to the ChatPPG research hub